
soupçon/ˈsuːpsɒn,ˈsuːpsɒ̃/ noun
1. a very small quantity of something; a slight trace, as of a particular taste or flavorSunday Soupçons is where I scribble mini-reviews for books I don’t have the brainspace/eloquence/smarts to write about in depth – or if I just don’t have anything interesting to say beyond I LIKED IT AND YOU SHOULD READ IT TOO!
It felt very Correct putting these two together, even though they’re so different!

Tales from Rugosa Coven by Sarah Avery
Genres: Adult, Fantasy, Contemporary Fantasy, Queer Protagonists, Urban Fantasy
Representation: Polyamorous MC with OCD
PoV: Third-person, past-tense
ISBN: 9781952456381
Goodreads
Catch a glimpse of a New Jersey even weirder than the one you think you know in this 2015 Mythopoeic Award winner, newly revised by the author. A covenful of very modern Wiccans wrestle challenges both supernatural and mundane—and, occasionally, each other. The personal injury attorney who chose kitchen-witchery over his family’s five-generation lineage of old school ceremonial magic would like to miss his dead parents, only now that they’re dead they won’t leave him alone. The professional fortuneteller stands out at forty paces, with her profusion of silver amulets glittering over her Goth wardrobe, but nobody has guessed her secret sorrow, especially not the covenmates who see her as their wacky comic relief. And the resident skeptic, a reluctant Pagan if ever there was one, will have to eat her words if her coven sister’s new boyfriend really does turn out to be from Atlantis. The Jersey Shore’s half-hidden community of Witches, Druids, and latter-day Vikings must circle together against all challenges. It’s a good thing they’re as resilient as the wild rugosa roses that hold together the dunes.
This was originally published way back in 2013, and in 2015 it won the Mythopoeic Fantasy Award (one of the few book awards I pay any attention to, since I am a big fan of mythopoeia!) I read and loved it then, and was SO EXCITED when Candlemark & Gleam announced they were publishing a new, updated and revised edition!
And WOW did it live up to all my hopes! I do in fact love this edition far more than the old one, and reading it was an utter delight. The included author’s note, where Avery explained the changes made, was also great, and I very much appreciated both her candour in discussing where she’d made mistakes before, and her thoughts behind the process of making changes.
Tales From Rugosa Coven is, shockingly, a collection of tales following some of the witches of Rugosa Coven. (I know, bet you never saw that coming!) It’s actually three novellas, and the length of each is very satisfying – I’m glad they weren’t short stories instead. The Rugosa witches are Wiccans, and if you have any familiarity with the community at all, you can imagine my delight at how they are surrounded by, and constantly interact with, witches from a bunch of other magical traditions – druids are the LEAST of it. In Avery’s stories, magic is very real, but not in the sense of Hollywood special effects; instead it’s very close to what practising Wiccan magic is actually like, but with a bit more oomph. This is not an Urban Fantasy setting in the usual sense; it’s our world, so the vast majority of people don’t believe in magic, and there are no werewolves or vampires, no ‘secret magical underbelly’ of New Jersey.
…Except kinda? But it’s just the real-world neopagan community – perfectly normal people, people who could be your neighbours or members of the local PTA. Who also work magic, when you’re not watching. I thought Avery did a WONDERFUL job at capturing the feeling of the community, of the different faiths and paths, and I think it’s done in a way that is perfectly accessible to people who aren’t and never have been part of that community. (Several of the changes Avery made to the new edition helped facilitate that.)
So, three novellas: Closing Arguments, And Ria’s From Virgo, and Atlantis Cranks Need Not Apply. Closing Arguments follows Bob as he tries to wrangle his parents’ estate after their sudden, simultaneous death; And Ria’s From Virgo has Ria doing her best to get treatment for her OCD without losing her job; and Atlantis Cranks Need Not Apply focusses on Jane, the coven’s sceptic. All three are really fun, but what makes them special is the frankly magical way Avery manages to blend the domestic and mundane with the supernatural. It’s this very…frank, matter-of-fact approach to things that are objectively bonkers – Bob’s parents, despite being deceased, are leaving him notes and demanding he burn their house down; Ria reads tarot for a living, and an ex gets her entangled with an urban legend; poor Jane has to re-evaluate her ENTIRE worldview when it turns out Atlantis may exist after all, actually.
And it’s all just – wonderfully, delightfully…I don’t know the right word: is there anything that means something like mundane or prosaic that doesn’t have a connotation of boring or lesser? Because that’s what Avery achieves here, this beautifully homey feeling, the perfect blend of the mundane and magical. It’s what I always want Urban Fantasy to be and almost never get; the tensions of child-raising when one of you is a witch and the other isn’t; managing a day-job and the ghosts of your parents who will not shut up; the difficulty of finding a psychiatrist who doesn’t think your witchcraft is a symptom of mental illness; juggling workplace tensions when the new hire wants to set up an altar to Odin in what has previously been your space. It doesn’t make the magic boring – I think it works the other way, making the everyday more magical. And also making the magic feel very real, very of course, not taken for granted but inextricable and undeniable.
I loved it. It was so much fun, and really warm and soft without being fluffy. A hot chocolate book, I think. It’s one I’ll definitely revisit on grey-brain days!

Light & Earth & Marrow by Jeannie Marschall
Genres: Adult, Fantasy, Contemporary Fantasy, Queer Protagonists
Representation: Sapphic MC, F/F
PoV: Third-person, past-tense
Published on: 22nd September 2026
ISBN: 1970458100
Goodreads
Hedge witch Tilly Reinicke resides in a bucolic village where magic and all manner of paranormal creatures are real—everyone knows it, but not everyone is necessarily kenning.
Tilly passes the quiet seasons alongside her dead but far-from-gone wife Ralda, cultivating their garden, respecting the Others, and teaching the children the ways and the Paths… until their peace is shattered by the rumble of construction next door.
Her new neighbors, Yola and Karsten Bell, are determined to control every last detail of their new home build… and are decidedly not kenning. As the nights grow longer and the most hallowed day of the year approaches, Tilly tries her very, grumpy best to guide, cajole, and reason with the Bells, before their unbelief in—and contempt for—the paranormal world endangers everyone.
For the Others do not suffer disrespect lightly, and soon they will walk the Paths again.
I received this book for free from the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
I don’t have anything clever to say about this one – it’s exactly what it claims to be, what it presents itself as. Which is not cosy fantasy, but it does start off very charming, even idyllic. Tilly is a middle-aged witch living comfortably with her garden, her familiar cat Tom, and the ghost of her wife, Ralda; she’s a well-respected (and adored by the local children) member of the community. Including the magical community; over the course of the novella it becomes clear that she’s well-known to the Others, supernatural beings who don’t spend a lot of time in our plane of existence. But lots of other magical creatures do; I was ridiculously delighted by the inclusion of wolpertingers, which are rabbits or hares with antlers and wings. They don’t get utilised enough in fantasy stories, imo!
Conflict arrives with new neighbours, Yola and Karsten, who have less than zero interest in the fact that their property is crossed by many Paths – the ways magic, and magical creatures and beings, move over the world. Yola and Karsten want a fence, and despite Tilly’s advice, they don’t arrange it so the fence doesn’t go down to the ground (leaving a gap at the base allows magic AND hedgehogs to wander freely, apparently). This is far from the last of their callously careless missteps, unfortunately.
Obviously this is a metaphor for living in an environmentally friendly way – more than that, living in a way that’s friendly to your local environment, to the beasties and birds and insects who live alongside you, and the earth under your feet. It’s not as simple as avoiding greenhouse gases and making sure to recycle – the lifestyle Tilly embodies is less passive than that; it’s not about trying to make no mark on the world, but actively trying to make a positive one, a distinction that hasn’t occurred to me before and that I really, REALLY like. There’s a joyfulness to it that winds throughout the novella and strikes a really beautiful chord.
One of the things that elevates Light & Earth & Marrow is that it’s set in a world – or the future – where humanity is aware that magic and magical creatures exist. Yola and Karsten defend their actions by pointing out that they have followed all the rules and laws about not offending the Others – because laws like that apparently exist here! (Though as Tilly says, the laws are well-meaning, but not enough, especially when dealing with people who only care about meeting the letter, not the spirit, of the law.) Even non-witches work hard to participate in the relationship between humanity and not-humanity; the chapter where Tilly’s community gathers for candle-making and good food to prepare for Samhain is one of my favourites in the book.
It was genuinely funny (at least at first) to be so able to understand Yola and Karsten, and simultaneously hold them in such contempt. Tilly absolutely breaches what most people would consider good manners in her efforts to educate these two idiots, and part of me cringed with discomfort every time she hit my standard for ‘rude’. But it’s important! Sometimes you’ve gotta be rude! What’s she supposed to do, be ‘polite’ by not telling them how badly they’re fucking up? That helps nobody! But like – Yola and Karsten are such typical, ‘normal’ white cishet people, earnest and polite (…to a point, anyway). In another story, they’d be great neighbours – they introduce themselves with fruitcake, and bring Tilly a whole basket of goodies to thank her for her help on one occasion. They’re Nice PeopleTM.
last rites and last rights of nature
But this is, in part, a story about how shallow and worthless ‘nice’ is; about how many Nice PeopleTM are only nice when things are going their way, when they are getting what they want. Yola and Karsten aren’t willing to give up any of what they want to be in harmony with others, and they definitely don’t respect the fact that the Others are so much older than them or their house – that by most lights the Others were there first. It’s not even that these idiots don’t care about not-humans; they don’t care about humans either! All of Tilly’s and the town’s efforts and invites are rejected; these two have no interest in being part of any community, it seems like.
And that…feels very pointed. All my adult life, I’ve not been part of the community around where I live – school communities, sure, but I’ve never known my neighbours, never taken part in local events and things. And I think most urban people are the same, at least in the countries I’ve lived in. We socialise at and around school and work, but not at home, and now I think about it, how weird and sad is that? How are we supposed to forge a positive connection with the natural world around us if we can’t even foster connections with the other humans around us???
Don’t tempt fate nor fae,
This is a charming, beautiful little novella; it’s extremely cathartic, with zero mercy or grace for those who won’t compromise with the natural world – ‘Be silent, or be next’ indeed!!!; and even better, it’s left me with LOTS to think about. I very much approve!
Have you read any good witchy books lately?






Leave a Reply